RFC 267 UNKNOWN NETWORK OPERATIONS · ARPANET

Network Host Status

ARPANET host status for November 8-19, 1971, noting new users and servers.

On rfc-editor.org ↗
PUBLISHED
November 1971
AUTHORS
E. Westheimer
STREAM
Legacy
BUILDS ON
RFC 266 — Network host status
OBSOLETED BY
RFC 287 — Status of Network Hosts
REPORT PERIOD
November 8-19, 1971
NEW SERVER
SDC IBM-360/67
NEW USER
Lincoln TX2
HOSTS TESTED
12 sites
DOI
10.17487/RFC0267

RFC text

Original text · RFC Editor View on rfc-editor.org ↗
Network Working Group                                 Ellen Westheimer
RFC #267                                              BBN
NIC #7815                                             22 November 1971
Categories:  F, G.3
Updates: RFC #266
Obsoletes  None

      This RFC reports on the status of most Network Hosts from November
8  to  November 19.  On November 18, however, the BBN prototype Terminal
IMP (Network Address 158) was inaccessible due to hardware debugging.

      Several Hosts are  currently  excluded  fron  the  daily  testing.
These Hosts fall into two categories:

      1)  Hosts which are not expected to be functioning on
          the Network as servers (available for use from
          other sites) for at least two weeks.  Included here
          are:

          Network
          Address        Site             Computer

            71           Rand             PDP-10
            74           Lincoln          TX2
            13           Case             PDP-10
            14           Carnegie         PDP-10
            15           Ames             B6500
            16           Ames             IBM-360/67

      2)  Hosts which are curently intended to be users only.
          Included here are the Terminal IMPs, which are
          presently in the Network (AMES, MITRE, and BBN*).
          This category also includes the Network Control
          Center Computer (Network Address 5) which is used
          solely for gathering statistics from the Network.
          Finally, included among these Hosts are the following:

          Network
          Address        Site             Computer

             7           Rand             IBM-360/65
            73           Harvard          PDP-1
            12           Illinois         PDP-11

      During these two weeks the Lincoln Labs TX2 Hosts became a Network
User.  The SDC IBM 360/67 is now a server.

The tables on the next two pages summarize the information on Host
status for this period.

* The BBN Terminal IMP (Network Address 158) is a prototype and
as such is frequently not connected to the Network, but being
used to refine and debug the Terminal IMP programs.

NETWORK                            STATUS or            STATUS or
ADDRESS    SITE        COMPUTER    PREDUCTION           PREDUCTION
                                                        OBTAINED FROM

   1       UCLA        SIGMA-7     Server               Jon Postel
   5       UCLA        IBM-360/91  Remote Job Service
                                    now, Telnet in
                                    April               Bob Braden
   2       SRI
             (NIC)     PDP-10      Server               John Melvin
  66       SRI
             (AI)      PDP-10      "Soon"               Len Chaiten
   3       UCSB        IBM-360/75  Server               Jim White
   4       UTAH        PDP-10      "Soon"               Barry Wessler
  *5       BBN
             (NCC)     DDP-516     Never                Alex McKenzie
  69       BBN
             (TENEX)   PDP-10      Server               Dan Murphy
   6       MIT
             (Multics) H-645       Server               Mike Padlipsky
  70       MIT
             (DM)      PDP-10      Server               Bob Bressler
  *7       RAND        IBM-360/65  User only            Eric Harslem
 *71       RAND        PDP-10      January '72          Eric Harslem
   8       SDC         IBM-360/67  Server               Bob Long
   9       HARVARD     PDP-10      Server               Bob Sundberg
 *73       HARVARD     PDP-1       User only            Bob Sundberg
  20       LINCOLN     IBM-360/67  "Soon"               Joel Winnet
 *74       LINCOLN     TX2         December             Tom Barkalow
  11       STANFORD    PDP-10      "Soon"               Andy Moorer
 *12       ILLINOIS    PDP-11      User only            John Cravits
 *13       CASE        PDP-10      March '72            Charles Rose
 *14       CARNEGIE    PDP-10      January '72          Hal vanZoeren
 *15       AMES        B6500       September '72        John McConnel
 *16       AMES        IBM-360/67  January '72          Wayne Hathaway
*144       AMES        TIP         User only
*145       MITRE       TIP         User only
*158       BBN         TIP         User only
                  (Proto-type)

* host not included in daily testing.

NETWORK
ADDRESS   SITE       COMPUTER       DAY, DATE and TIME (Eastern)

                                   M      Tu       W       Th      F
                                 11/8    11/9    11/10   11/11   11/12

  1     UCLA         SIGMA-7       O       D       O       O       O
*65     UCLA         IBM-360/91    O       D       O       D       O
  2     SRI (NIC)    PDP-10        O       O       O       O       T
 66     SRI (AI)     PDP-10        D       D       D       D       D
  3     UCSB         IBM-360/75    O       T       O       O       D
  4     UTAH         PDP-10        D       D       H       D       D
 69     BBN (TENEX)  PDP-10        H       O       O       O       O
  6     MIT (Mulics) H-645         D       D       D       O       O
 70     MIT (DM)     PDP-10        O       H       T       D       O
  8     SDC          IBM-360/67   #D      #D      #D      #D      #D
  9     HARVARD      PDP-10        D       D       D       D       T
 10     LINCOLN      IBM-360/67    H       H       H       H       D
 11     STANFORD     PDP-10        D       T       D       D       D


                                   M       Tu       W       F
                                 11/15   11/16    11/17   11/19

  1     UCLA         SIGMA-7       O       O       O       O
*65     UCLA         IBM-360/91    O       O       D       O
  2     SRI (NIC)    PDP-10        T       T       O       O
 66     SRI (AI)     PDP-10        D       D       D       D
  3     UCSB         IBM-360/75    O       O       O       O
  4     UTAH         PDP-10        D       D       D       D
 69     BBN (TENEX)  PDP-10        O       D       O       O
  6     MIT (Mulics) H-645         T       D       O       H
 70     MIT (DM)     PDP-10        O       O       O       D
  8     SDC          IBM-360/67   #D      #D      #D      #D
  9     HARVARD      PDP-10        T       D       D       T
 10     LINCOLN      IBM-360/67    D       H       D       D
 11     STANFORD     PDP-10        D       D       D       D

where

   D = Dead (Destination Host either dead or inaccessible [due to
             network partitioning or local IMP failure] from the BBN
             Terminal IMP.)

   R = Refused (Destination Host returned a CLS to the initial RFC.)

   T = Timed out (Destination Host did not respond in any way to the
             initial RFC, although not dead.)

   H = 1/2 Open (Destination Host opened a connection but then either
             immediately closed it, or did not respond further.)

   O = Open (Destination Host opened a connection and was accessible to
             users.)


   * The UCLA IBM-360/91 currently has Remote Job Service (NETRJS),
     but has not implemented a full server Telnet System.  The BBN
     Terminal IMP is not equipped to test NETRJS; however, we are
     assuming that receipt of the UCLA explanatory message indicates
     that NETRJS is also functioning.

   # These sites advertise that they may not have their system
     available at these times.

       [ This RFC was put into machine readable form for entry ]
         [ into the online RFC archives by Simone Demmel 1/98 ]

AI ELI5

On this page
PROBLEMARPANET operators needed to track the growing number of nodes and their changing roles as servers or users.
MECHANISMBBN continued biweekly status reports with daily reachability tests and updates on which hosts were excluded from testing.
EXPANDING ROLESLincoln's TX2 became a user host, and SDC's IBM-360 became a server, continuing the network's growth.

§1Introduction and Exclusions

RFC 267 reports on ARPANET host status from November 8 to November 19, 1971. On November 18 the BBN Terminal IMP was offline for hardware debugging. The report lists hosts excluded from daily testing in two categories: those not expected to be servers for at least two weeks (Rand PDP-10, Lincoln TX2, Case, Carnegie, Ames B6500 and IBM-360), and user-only hosts (Terminal IMPs and the Network Control Center). During this period, Lincoln's TX2 became a network user and SDC's IBM-360 became a server.

A report from mid-November showed which computers were tested, which ones were skipped, and noted that one computer changed from being tested to being left alone.

§2Daily Test Results

Two tables summarize host status for November 8-12 and November 15-19 (November 18 was excluded due to Terminal IMP downtime). Tests used status codes where O meant open, D meant dead, T meant timeout, H meant half-open, and R meant refused. Some sites advertised unavailable times. UCLA's IBM-360 is now explicitly noted to provide Remote Job Service only, without a Telnet server.

Tables showed each day's test results for 12 hosts, using the same letter codes to mark how each computer responded.

§3Host Predictions and Server Status

The report includes host status predictions from operators, showing expected dates when hosts would become servers (for example, Case predicted March 1972, Carnegie predicted January 1972). Most major hosts like UCLA, SRI NIC, UCSB, and MIT Multics were servers or soon would be. SDC was now confirmed as a server after this period. Some hosts like Stanford and Illinois remained user-only or had uncertain status.

Site operators said when their computers would be ready to help others, and the test results showed which ones were already working.

§4References